Discussion and Analysis by Grace Gliksten
It has been reported that Prime Minister Theresa May won ministerial support to increase the Brexit offer from €20bn to €40bn yesterday. May is hoping that the increase will unlock stalled negotiations, but has been warned by Eurosceptic colleagues that this is conditional upon securing good transition and trade agreements with the EU. The increase is intended to close the gap between the UK’s initial offer of €20bn and the €60bn expected by the EU.
Ministers have speculated that the promise from the UK to respect its outstanding EU commitments could mean a bill of €40bn to €50bn. While the UK accepts some obligations, there are several questions surrounding the full details of these. These include the issue of pensions for EU staff, and how the UK’s contribution is calculated. Another contentious issue surrounds the question of building projects that have had funding approved by all EU states, but where work will not start until the Article 50 process has been completed.
The increase was approved by a 10-member subcommittee in Downing Street yesterday. One minister said, “there is consensus behind the prime minister’s position – for now.” Foreign Secretary, Boris Johnson, was part of the subcommittee and one of the members who agreed that the increased offer should be dependent upon the EU opening transition talks in December and settling on an encouraging trade agreement next year. Another member who agreed with Johnson said, “it has to be something for something … this can’t be unconditional money.” Eurosceptic ministers have also said, however, that Britain should be prepared to walk out of talks if a bad trade deal is proposed by the EU. This follows the same tone as May who said, “nothing is agreed until everything is agreed”.
May is expected to wait until the last possible moment before making her improved financial offer. She has confirmed that the offer will only be made when she is sure that it will break the stalemate in negotiations ahead of the EU summit next month. 8th December has been signalled by officials as the date the offer will be made, despite Michel Barnier’s, the EU chief negotiator, pressure to deliver the proposal by the end of this week.
May is holding off on the offer in order to gain the most leverage in negotiations.. May is waiting for assurances from EU leaders that the proposal would be received favourably and wants the European Council to declare that first round talks have made “sufficient progress”. She wants the increased offer to help open talks on the transition deal and trade agreements.
Negotiations have been complicated by the current political uncertainty in Germany. The breakdown of talks to form a coalition under Chancellor, Angela Merkel, has left Germany in an unprecedented political crisis. With both the coalition and Merkel’s position unclear, May has been encouraged to exploit the current weakness. However, Thomas Matussek, former German ambassador to the UK, said, “I think German instability is bad news for Britain.” Moderating these comments, he added that he believes that the problems in Berlin would make “no operational difference” to the EU’s position on Brexit.
The Pound has benefited from positive Brexit news, improving across the board since the decision. Against the Euro, German political instability has exacerbated Sterling’s strength. The Pound rose 0.69 percent against the Euro, moving from 1.1230 to 1.1305, still short of the gains made at the end of October. It also increased 0.59 percent against the US Dollar, from 1.3175 to 1.3264.
Germany In just 6 weeks Germany will vote and while Chancellor Scholz thinks that he can win, most others are equally convinced that he cannot based on his economic record alone that has seen the German economy contract by 0.3% in 2023 and by an estimated 0.2% in 2024. That on top of his ability […]
British Pound With a GBP 4 billion auction of 10 Year Gilts today, markets are watching carefully as higher long term rates put pressure on the UK Chancellor and GBP bounces around between USD 1.21 and 1.22. After 6 consecutive trading sessions with GBP weaker and a low of 1.2097 which has taken its toll, […]
Europe With EU annual inflation coming in at 2.4% up from 2.2%, conventional wisdom might suggest that that might dampen the ECB’s enthusiasm for an early cut in EUR interest rates at the end of January. But such is the weakness pervading the EU economies, it is more likely that the hawkish tendencies at the […]